Rick Reynolds, LCSW
by Rick Reynolds, LCSW
Founder & President, Affair Recovery

Ending An Affair: Throw Away the Key

On the day I married Stephanie, I swore I would love her till death do us part. I wanted to be a man who loved his wife, a man who would protect her and provide for her. I wanted to be a good father and a man of great integrity. I never fathomed that I would ever dishonor or disrespect Stephanie. My heart was to love her to the best of my ability. That sentiment reflects my true heart. At the core of my being is a heart that loves and is compassionate, kind, concerned, and caring. However, I have other parts of my being that want and need to be loved. I want and need to feel good about myself.

All of us live in a state of duality.

To please both sides is impossible.

I say that in an attempt to help those of you closing the door on infidelity understand why throwing away the key is a necessity. The other side of me that wanted the affair is both crafty and cunning. While my true self wants to return home, there's a good chance the part of me that entered into the affair may still crave those feelings of affirmation.

Failure to throw away the key leaves me vulnerable to something I know my true self does not want.

If you've betrayed your heart and fallen into self-deception, self-sabotage remains an eminent threat. This leaves you as your own worst enemy. Avoiding self-sabotage requires guarding your own motivations and actions. Here are a few pitfalls that can unintentionally sabotage our resolve when ending an affair.

Guilt and Shame

Feelings of guilt and shame generated by terminating the relationship create temptation to contact the affair partner (AP) to let them know how badly you feel for disrupting their life. While the thought of trying to help their pain might seem noble, the basis is self-centered. Telling them you feel badly for hurting them only fortifies your image in their eyes and reinforces their attachment to you. Pretending to be the good guy may help with the guilt and shame, but it does little or nothing to help your AP move on. You don't need them to tell you that they're hurting any more than you need to tell them that you're hurting, because you're already aware of that reality. This temptation to let them know how you're doing is only a dimly veiled attempt by your other side to sabotage your recovery.

Four years after my affair, I remember telling Stephanie that I still felt badly about what I'd done to my AP. I asked what she thought about me calling her and letting her know how badly I still felt for hurting her and her family. "Haven't you already done that?" she asked. "Why do you feel a need to do it again?" As I thought about it, I realized that even after all those years there was a part of me that was still vulnerable to the temptation of contacting my old AP. I agreed with Stephanie and never made the call.

I now realize that part of my problem was a failure to forgive myself for what I'd done. As long as I failed to accept that I was forgiven, as long as I had that unmet need, I was in danger of allowing guilt to serve as the key for unlocking that door of communicating with her again.

It's our inability to forgive ourselves that leaves us vulnerable.

Wayward partners, you don't need your AP to forgive you, nor do you need them to be okay with what's happened before you move on. You must fully let go of that relationship to move forward. Circumstances have changed for you both and you each have equal opportunity to make new choices and find new beginnings. The temptation to tell the other party how badly you feel is especially strong if you played the role of rescuer in your extramarital relationship. It's time to let go of the self-deception that tells you they can't get along without you.

As much as the truth hurts, your AP will very likely do much better without you. Maybe you helped for a time. Maybe you didn't. Either way, it's not your responsibility anymore.

A technique to move beyond this temptation is to write yourself a letter as if it's from your AP telling you how well they've done since you've both moved on. The story you tell yourself doesn't have to be one of doom and gloom. It's far more likely they'll do well! Allow that reality to be a part of the story you tell as you write the letter.

The "Someday" Vision

Eliminating the belief that maybe someday, "life will bring us together," is critical in throwing away the key. If you hang on to the dream that you might someday get back together, you'll never fully move on. Tell yourself this relationship is permanently over and always will be. The future has to be rewritten.

Typically, those in affairs create an illusion of a future together. That dream of how life will be is often the most intriguing part of the relationship. While things might be miserable now, we imagine how wonderful it will be when our dreams all come true. In reality, tomorrow never comes. Since circumstances account for only 10% of happiness, even if we had the life we've created in our head, it most likely wouldn't satisfy. If you can't do it today, you certainly won't be able to do it tomorrow. Even worse, believing that someday you'll have the right circumstances to make you happy will impede your motivation to do the necessary work to find your own internal source of peace.

Deciding this relationship will never be is critical.

Failure to do so hinders your ability to dream and cast a new future. Even if your current relationship doesn't work out, the dynamics that made that relationship appealing will no longer be in place. Let it go. While it's scary letting go of that fantasy, it's a must. You'll never experience new beginnings as long as you close yourself off to new possibilities by clinging to a fantasy. Once you accept that it will never be, a whole new world will open up to you. Self-sabotage will become far less likely.

Breaking the Ties that Bind

"The parts of the story that remain untold
are the places where the devil has a stronghold."

-Dan Allender, American therapist and author

Eliminating secrets is essential to throwing away the key. It's not that your mate needs to know all the gory details, but you at least need to bring to light the secrets involving your AP.

If there's contact of any kind, let your mate know. Even if it's them attempting to contact you, it needs to be brought to the light. Maintaining any type of deception leaves you vulnerable to heading back down that path.

Intimacy with your mate is crucial to rebuilding trust and shifting the loyalty in your heart. If you hold secrets to protect your AP, you'll never fully break the tie. That secret will leave you forever in a covert relationship with your AP. Breaking the code of silence frees you from having to protect the AP and allows you to move back toward your mate.

Living in the Past

The final pathway to self-sabotage is the euphoric recall. Life happens in the moment, not in some past event. It's tempting to dwell on ecstatic moments generated during the period of infidelity. (Have you ever noticed how it's not tempting to fantasize about the lousy moments the two of you had together?)

The part of you that wants to focus on those fantasies isn't your true self. It's the part that's interested in self-gratification at the expense of others.

One way to combat this temptation is to ask yourself what you've done lately to create that sort of delight for those in your family. To throw away the key, your focus has to be on how well you're loving others rather than evaluating how well others are loving you. You have to maintain a heart of compassion and concern rather than seeing others as objects you need to manage in order to get your needs met. Essentially, it's rooting out that selfish mindset and patterns of behavior that will help you love your family.

Living in either the past or future will rob you of life's reality and leave you incapable of loving others. Ending an affair requires learning to find enjoyment in each of life's moments. It requires being awake and aware of life's blessings on a daily basis.

Once you've thrown away the key by fortifying yourself against self-sabotage, there's only one more step: let go and move on.


At Affair Recovery, our hope is for you to find an extraordinary life of meaning and purpose. Believe it or not, your (or your spouse's) infidelity can serve as a catalyst to move you to better places. Don't let what's been the worst part of your life cause you to believe life will never be what you want.

Sections: 

RL_Category: 

RL_Media Type: 

Add New Comment:

Comments

affair ending

In my case, I met my affair partner in a chatroom for married cheaters. Turns out she lurked there looking for men she could manipulate with sex. After running away with her 2 things became apparent;
1. True lovemaking only exists between true lovers. The porn industry sells the idea that you are missing out on giant pleasure, and your wife cannot compete with the scripted actresses. The average orgasm in men is 5 seconds, and the manner of stimulus is irrelevant. So I ran and destroyed my family pursuing a phantom. The thrill and the brain chemistry that makes you infatuated with AP dissappear. Leaving a realization in maybe both affair partners that trust is impossible.
2. I was not that woman's type, and she rarely desired me as a lover, and blamed her lack of pleasure on lithium. Plausible but I saw it as professional homewrecker. She kept upping the demands, pressing me to destroy my wife and giv her the whole package, house, income and even termination of my wife's parental rights. Then I woke up. My wife took me back with conditions and we are fiends that love each other, but total trust and respect are gone forever. Every now and then she calls me out for minimalizing that choice even after 25 years. I mourn the loss of the woman who loved me unconditionally.

One of my best friends

One of my best friends experienced probably similar to what your wife experienced in her marriage, but in the end that marriage dissolved. To her credit, she had tried to move past the infidelities, but (thankfully in a way) her husband was the one to finally seek a divorce so he could essentially do whatever he wanted to do.
She eventually met an incredible man, who saw her worth and has treated her with great worth ever since, has never been unfaithful and who has consistently proved himself trustworthy, loving and just generally the dream! They have 3 kids and in so many ways she has the life she has always wanted. But she also says despite her second husband's faithfulness and honouring of her, she remains completely uncapable of trusting him. She makes a choice every morning to try and trust as much as possible and to be vulnerable and to give herself to the marriage, but she is never able to relax into feeling that she can trust anyone.
I think sadly that part of the consequence of these deeply intimate kinds of betrayal, by the person you love most and have trusted most, is that it just breaks something in you that cannot be put back together. Yes you can still have a good and great marriage, yes you can forgive, yes you can learn and help others based on your experiences, there are lots of positive things that can still happen. But trust is just one of the casualties that it seems is affected forever, no matter how faithful the spouse is after the betrayals.
Maybe that can give you some comfort, that with your wife her lack of trust now most likely isn't based on anything you are doing now, it's just something that will always be broken after the point of that initial break. Because it does feel like your whole world has fallen apart when the person you chose to trust most, pulls a fast one on you. The foundations just sort of shake, and never fully go back together.

affair ending

Similar scenario but went to there out of hurt after finding out last year about my husbands "one time" affair 26 years ago. I am finding the demands of it are not what I want any longer..guess I got the revenge out of my system. Should I just ignore and avoid contact with AP. He hasnt done anything but we talk everyday and then he wants to arrange the next encounter. I'm over it but just want to run without explanation.

I'll be honest when you say

I'll be honest when you say you want to contact the affair partner 'to let them know how badly you feel for disrupting their life', even the very statement is nonsensical. They were as guilty as you in their actions. Their actions were commensurate with yours in as far as they also knew that you were married, and so they knew their actions were actively breaking up a home. Nothing would have happened if they hadn't agreed to it.
Yes, the betraying spouse in one sense is more guilty towards their own spouse, as they cheated on someone they knew and had at one point loved, and someone they made big promises to. But the affair partner was as equally guilty as them in actions that break a marriage covenant. They don't need apologised to, they should actually be the one to apologise to the betrayed spouse for having treated them and their marriage with utter disrespect.
I get that you are pointing out the wilyness people have in justifying trying to get back in touch with someone who made them feel good with no strings attached, but am just trying to point out that the argument of apologising to them is not something that a betrayed spouse could ever find valid. It takes two to be unfaithful, and both the betraying spouse and the affair partner are equally guilty in that light.

Broken hearted Cop

I had an emotional affair with someone I worked with. He told me he wanted to focus on his 30 year marriage. I created this alternate universe in my mind of a life with him. He’s 60 I’m 40. Anyway we left the restaurant, and we wound up having sex in the back of the car. I can’t stop thinking about him. How do I get over him and focus on my family, my life…I don’t know if I want to save my marriage. Why did I fall so hard for the AP? Will the hurt ever go away? I’m do sad.

What type of affair was it?

Our free Affair Analyzer provides you with insights about your unique situation and gives you a personalized plan of action.
Take the Affair Analyzer

Free Surviving Infidelity Bootcamp

Our experts designed this step-by-step guide to help you survive infidelity. Be intentional with your healing with this free 7-day bootcamp.
head-silhouette
 
I would highly recommend giving this a try.
 
-D, Texas